Ordination of women in Anglicanism

From AnglicanWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Ordination of women in Anglicanism is the admission of women to the threefold ordained ministry of deacon, priest, and bishop. For most of Christian history, and in the historic Anglican formularies, ordination to these offices was reserved to men; the ordination of women is a recent innovation, beginning in the twentieth century and spreading province by province from the 1970s onward. The practice remains contested within the Anglican Communion: many provinces now ordain women to the priesthood, some ordain women to the diaconate only, and others ordain men only. There is no Communion-wide canon on the subject; each province, and often each diocese, decides for itself.[1]

The historic pattern and the deaconess order

The ancient Church knew an order of deaconesses, attested in the New Testament (Phoebe, Romans 16:1) and in the early centuries, which disappeared in the West by about the tenth century and later in the East.[2] The order's disappearance is commonly attributed to the decline of adult baptism and to the development of the diaconate as a first step toward the priesthood.[2]

The modern revival of the deaconess order began outside Anglicanism. In 1836 the Lutheran pastor Theodor Fliedner founded a deaconess institute at Kaiserswerth, Germany, training women in community for nursing, teaching, and parish visiting.[3] Florence Nightingale trained at Kaiserswerth, and the Kaiserswerth model spread through Europe and to England and North America.

In the Church of England, the first deaconess to be authorized by a bishop was Elizabeth Ferard, set apart by the Bishop of London in 1862; she had founded the North London Deaconess Institution in 1861.[2] From England the movement spread through the Anglican Communion. In the United States, the Protestant Episcopal Church passed a canon in 1889 giving the deaconess a degree of recognition.[2] The status of the office long remained ambiguous — whether a deaconess was ordained, appointed for life, or free to marry was disputed — and the Lambeth Conference addressed it repeatedly. In 1968 the Lambeth Conference endorsed the principle that deaconesses are within the diaconate, while referring the question of women's ordination to the priesthood to the provinces for further study.[4]

The deaconess must be distinguished from ordination to the diaconate. A deaconess was set apart for a recognized ministry of service, teaching, and pastoral care, but was not ordained as a deacon in holy orders, and the office carried no path to the priesthood. Later, when provinces began ordaining women as deacons, the deaconess order was generally absorbed or discontinued in those provinces. Where male-only ordination is maintained, the lay office of deaconess has sometimes been restored instead: the Reformed Episcopal Church, for example, states that it has restored "the ancient and Biblical lay Office of Deaconess" as a ministry for women distinct from Holy Orders.[5] See Deaconess.

First ordinations: Hong Kong and the diaconate

The first woman ordained to the priesthood in the Anglican Communion was Florence Li Tim-Oi, ordained on 25 January 1944 in Hong Kong by Ronald Hall, Bishop of Victoria, where wartime conditions had left congregations without priests.[6] Her ordination was exceptional and controversial, and it was thirty years before the practice became widespread. The next women ordained priests in Hong Kong, Jane Hwang and Joyce M. Bennett, followed in 1971.[7]

In the years following the 1968 Lambeth Conference's endorsement of deaconesses within the diaconate, several provinces began ordaining women to the diaconate.[4] The diaconate thus became the first order widely opened to women, a decade or more before priestly ordination spread.

The Episcopal Church

The Episcopal Church in the United States was the first province in which women's priestly ordination became a church-dividing public controversy. Its General Convention authorized the ordination of women as deacons in 1970. On 29 July 1974, eleven women deacons were ordained priests at the Church of the Advocate, Philadelphia, by three retired bishops, although the church had not yet authorized women's priestly ordination; the ordinations were widely regarded as irregular.[8] Four more women were ordained in Washington, D.C., on 7 September 1975.[8]

In September 1976 the General Convention voted to allow women to become priests and bishops, with canons effective 1 January 1977; the earlier irregular ordinations were subsequently regularized.[8] Regular ordinations of women to the priesthood began on 1 January 1977.[9] The first woman to become a bishop in the Anglican Communion was Barbara Harris, elected suffragan bishop of Massachusetts in 1988 and consecrated on 11 February 1989.[7] In 2006 Katharine Jefferts Schori was elected Presiding Bishop of the Episcopal Church, the first woman to serve as primate of a province in the Communion.[7]

Disagreement within the Episcopal Church did not end with authorization. In 1994 the General Convention affirmed that there was value in the theological position that women should not be ordained; in 1997 it revised the canons to prevent any diocese from denying access to the ordination process, or refusing to license clergy to officiate, solely on the grounds of gender.[9] The controversy contributed to the formation of the Continuing Anglican movement in 1977 and, later, to the Anglican realignment from which the Anglican Church in North America emerged (see below). As of 2024, the Episcopal Church counted 7,166 women clergy, active or retired.[8]

Canada, New Zealand, and Australia

In Canada, the General Synod passed enabling legislation for women priests in 1975, and the first six women priests in the Anglican Church of Canada were ordained on 30 November 1976, in four dioceses.[10] The first woman to become a bishop in Canada was Victoria Matthews, elected suffragan bishop of Toronto on 19 November 1993 and consecrated on 12 February 1994; she later became diocesan Bishop of Edmonton in 1997.[10]

In New Zealand, five women were ordained priests in 1977.[10]

In Australia, the General Synod legislated that women could be ordained as deacons in 1985 and as priests in 1992.[10] The first women priests in Australia were ordained in March 1992, beginning in Perth, followed by Canberra and Goulburn.[11] In 2007 the church's Appellate Tribunal agreed that there was nothing in the church's constitution to prevent the consecration of a woman as bishop, leaving the decision to individual dioceses.[10] The Diocese of Sydney, however, ordains women only to the diaconate, regardless of what is canonically possible in the wider church.[10] In 2018 Kay Goldsworthy, Archbishop of Perth, became the first woman to serve as an archbishop in the Australian church.[12]

England

The Church of England moved more slowly than the North American provinces. In 1975 the General Synod voted that there was "no fundamental objection" to the ordination of women to the priesthood.[13] Legislation authorizing the ordination of women as deacons was passed in 1986, and women were first ordained deacons in 1987.[14]

On 11 November 1992, after nineteen years of debate, the General Synod voted by the required two-thirds majorities in its Houses of Bishops, Clergy, and Laity to allow women's ordination to the priesthood, passing by a margin of only two votes in the House of Laity.[14] Thirty-two women were ordained priests at Bristol Cathedral on 12 March 1994; ordained in alphabetical order, Angela Berners-Wilson is officially the Church of England's first woman priest.[14] Provision was made for parishes and clergy who could not accept women's priestly ministry, first through the Act of Synod and later through the Five Guiding Principles adopted with the bishops legislation.

The episcopate followed two decades later. The General Synod approved legislation for women bishops in July 2014, with a final vote on 17 November 2014 removing the legal obstacles.[14] Libby Lane became the first woman to serve as a bishop in the Church of England when she was consecrated suffragan Bishop of Stockport on 26 January 2015.[14] Rachel Treweek became the first woman diocesan bishop in England when she became Bishop of Gloucester in July 2015.[15]

Other provinces

Elsewhere in the Communion, the pattern has been uneven. In Ireland, Janet Catterall became the first woman ordained an Anglican priest in 1990.[10] By 2014, women had served or were serving as bishops in the United States, Canada, New Zealand, Australia, Ireland, South Africa, South India, Wales, and the extra-provincial Episcopal Church of Cuba.[7] Dated counts illustrate the spread and its limits: by 2007, twenty-three of the thirty-eight provinces ordained women as priests, and eleven of those had removed all bars to women serving as bishops;[6] in 2011, seventeen of thirty-eight provinces consecrated women to the episcopate, while seven had yet to approve the ordination of women to any order of ministry.[16] Several provinces, including a number in Africa, continue to ordain men only, and within provinces that permit women's ordination, individual dioceses may decline to do so.

Theological arguments

The debate turns on Scripture, tradition, and sacramental theology, and both sides argue from within the Anglican tradition rather than from outside it. The arguments below are summarized with attribution; neither side's case is presented here as settled.

Supporters argue that Scripture portrays women in teaching, leadership, and apostolic ministry; that men and women are of equal dignity as bearers of God's image and joint-heirs in Christ, and are alike gifted by the Holy Spirit for ministry; and that the historic exclusion of women rested in part on now-discredited assumptions about women's capacities.[17] A 1962 Church of England report summarized the case for admission as resting on the emancipation of women and their admission to professions formerly reserved to men, on new insights that the assumed inferiority of women was "no longer self-evident," on the church's failure to provide an adequate ministry for women, and on the shortage of clergy.[18] Supporters also argue that diocesan freedom, as in the Anglican Church in North America, protects both practices: bishops and dioceses not convinced that women should be ordained should not be forced to do so, while dioceses that have decided in favor of the practice should continue to be authorized.[17]

Opponents argue that Scripture reserves the ordained offices to men: Christ chose only men as apostles, and the Pauline prohibitions on women teaching or exercising authority in the church (1 Corinthians 14:34; 1 Timothy 2:12) are understood, in the traditionalist reading, as excluding women from the office of setting forth and maintaining the church's teaching, analogous to the ordained ministry.[19] They argue from tradition as the handing on of "the faith once delivered to the saints" (Jude 3): the unbroken practice of the Church, East and West, excluded women from priesthood and episcopate, and a single province or national church has no authority to change unilaterally what belongs to the whole Church.[19] As one Australian critic of the change put it, the Church of England received the threefold ministry from the whole Church, so Anglicans "take no authority to change unilaterally that which belongs to the Church as a whole."[18] A sacramental form of the argument holds that the priest, presiding at the sacraments, acts in persona Christi, in the person of Christ, and that because Christ is male, only a male priest can represent him.[19] Opponents also argue ecumenically: women's ordination impairs communion with the Roman Catholic and Orthodox churches, which do not ordain women, and within Anglicanism itself it breaks the interchangeability of clergy and sacraments between dioceses that recognize women's orders and those that do not.[5]

The ACNA College of Bishops' 2017 statement acknowledged that "there are differing principles of ecclesiology and hermeneutics that are acceptable within Anglicanism that may lead to divergent conclusions regarding women's ordination to the priesthood," while also calling the practice "a recent innovation to Apostolic Tradition and Catholic Order" with "insufficient scriptural warrant" as standard provincial practice.[20] That double acknowledgment — divergent conclusions possible, innovation conceded — is why the same statement is cited by both sides.

The Anglican Church in North America

The Anglican Church in North America (ACNA), formed in 2009, maintains male-only ordination as the norm in some of its dioceses while permitting diocesan variation. Its Constitution provides that "[t]he Province shall make no canon abridging the authority of any member dioceses or networks ... with respect to its practice regarding the ordination of women to the diaconate or presbyterate," while its canons require a candidate for bishop to be "a male Presbyter at least 35 years old."[21] The Reformed Episcopal Church, a founding member of ACNA, ordains men only, by canon: "only males may be admitted as Postulants for Holy Orders in this Church."[22] The full account of ACNA's arrangement, its traditionalist rationale, and the question whether it is a provisional accommodation or a permanent settlement is given in Dual Integrity and Holy Orders in the Anglican Church in North America.

Continuing disagreement and current pattern

The ordination of women remains the most divisive internal question in contemporary Anglicanism. In provinces that permit it, provision for objectors varies from formal conscience clauses and alternative episcopal oversight to none at all; in the Church of England, the Five Guiding Principles continue to allow parishes to request a male priest or bishop on theological grounds. In provinces that do not permit it, the objection is generally stated not as a preference but as a matter of Scripture, tradition, and sacramental validity, with consequences for the recognition of orders and the sharing of Communion across diocesan lines. No Communion-wide settlement has been reached, and the pattern at present is one of provincial and diocesan diversity under a shared confession of the creeds, the Scriptures, and the historic episcopate — a diversity whose limits continue to be tested wherever clergy move between dioceses of differing practice.

See also

References

  1. ↑ For the pattern of provincial variation, see "Ordination of women in the Anglican Communion," https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ordination_of_women_in_the_Anglican_Communion (accessed November 3, 2026). Dated counts are given in the "Continuing disagreement" section below.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 R. T. Beckwith, "The Office of Woman in the Church, to the Present Day," in Why Not? Priesthood and the Ministry of Women, ed. Michael Bruce and G. E. Duffield (Marcham Manor Press, 1972), https://www.churchsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/Cman_083_3_Beckwith.pdf (accessed November 3, 2026).
  3. ↑ Centre for Christian Studies, "Diaconal History," http://ccsonline.ca/diakonia/diaconal-history/ (accessed November 3, 2026); Beckwith, "The Office of Woman in the Church."
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 Chronology in Women in the Priesthood: Questions and Answers (1972), https://archive.org/download/hewitt_hiatt1972/hewitt_hiatt1972_text.pdf (accessed November 3, 2026).
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 Bishops of the Reformed Episcopal Church, "A Pastoral Letter 2017," October 2, 2017, https://www.rechurch.org/resources/a-pastoral-letter-2017/ (accessed November 3, 2026).
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 "Ordination of women in the Anglican Communion," https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ordination_of_women_in_the_Anglican_Communion (accessed November 3, 2026).
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 "Ordination of women," https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/female_clergy (accessed November 3, 2026).
  8. ↑ 8.0 8.1 8.2 8.3 Episcopal News Service, "Episcopal Church marks 50th anniversary of the Philadelphia 11 ordinations," https://cms.episcopalchurch.org/episcopal-church-marks-50th-anniversary-of-the-philadelphia-11-ordinations/ (accessed November 3, 2026).
  9. ↑ 9.0 9.1 Diocese of West Texas, "Women in Priesthood in The Episcopal Church: Celebrating 50 Years," https://www.dwtx.org/la-ventana-article/women-in-priesthood-in-the-episcopal-church-celebrating-50-years (accessed November 3, 2026).
  10. ↑ 10.0 10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6 "Ordination of women in the Anglican Communion," https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ordination_of_women_in_the_Anglican_Communion (accessed November 3, 2026); Anglican Journal, "Women in the church," https://anglicanjournal.com/women-in-the-church-10134/ (accessed November 3, 2026).
  11. ↑ St Philip's Anglican Church, O'Connor, "Canon Ruth Jefferson celebrates communion at St Philip's in 1989," https://stphilipsoconnor.org.au/story/priests/jefferson.php (accessed November 3, 2026).
  12. ↑ "Timeline of women's ordination," https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_women's_ordination (accessed November 3, 2026).
  13. ↑ WATCH, "Timeline," https://www.womenandthechurch.org/timeline (accessed November 3, 2026).
  14. ↑ 14.0 14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4 Religion Media Centre, "Factsheet: Women priests in the Church of England," https://religionmediacentre.org.uk/factsheets/25-years-of-women-as-priests-in-the-church-of-england/ (accessed November 3, 2026).
  15. ↑ "Church of England," https://wiki.poast.org/wiki/C_of_e?lang=en (accessed November 3, 2026), recording the 2014 legislation and the 2015 consecrations.
  16. ↑ Anglican Journal, "Women in the church," https://anglicanjournal.com/women-in-the-church-10134/ (accessed November 3, 2026).
  17. ↑ 17.0 17.1 Diocese of Christ our Hope, "The Ministry of Women in the Church and the Ordination of Women as Deacons in the Diocese of Christ our Hope," September 23, 2017, https://caef817244d5f21ecddb-92c76cb1053f4e9ea0aba27a90d8d1b2.ssl.cf2.rackcdn.com/uploaded/m/0e11299713_1608058543_minstry-of-women.pdf (accessed November 3, 2026); Grant LeMarquand and William G. Witt, "A Biblical and Theological Defense of the Case for Allowing Women to Continue to be Ordained as Presbyters in the Anglican Church of North America" (written August 2018 at the bishops' request), https://willgwitt.org/theology/women-in-holy-orders/comment-page-1/ (accessed November 3, 2026).
  18. ↑ 18.0 18.1 Mavis Rose, "Debate on the Ordination of Women," in Freedom From Sanctified Sexism, https://womenpriests.org/ecumenism/rose-11-debate-on-the-ordination-of-women/ (accessed November 3, 2026).
  19. ↑ 19.0 19.1 19.2 Theological Task Force on Holy Orders, "Section IV: The Arguments For and Against," http://anglicancompass.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/HolyOrdersTaskForce_Section-4_Arguments-For-and-Against.pdf (accessed November 3, 2026).
  20. ↑ College of Bishops, "A Statement from the College of Bishops on the Ordination of Women," September 7, 2017, https://anglicanchurch.net/college-of-bishops-statement-on-the-ordination-of-women/ (accessed November 3, 2026).
  21. ↑ Anglican Church in North America, Constitution and Canons, as ratified June 2009 and amended June 2026, Constitution, art. VIII, § 2; Title III, Canon 8, § 3, https://anglicanchurch.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/ACNA-CC-RATIFIED-2026-06-25.pdf (accessed November 3, 2026).
  22. ↑ Reformed Episcopal Church, Constitution and Canons, as adopted 2026 (version 3.9), Canon 7, § 9, https://www.rechurch.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/REC_Constitution_and_Canons-2026.pdf (accessed November 3, 2026).
Retrieved from "https://www.anglicanwiki.org/index.php?title=Ordination_of_women_in_Anglicanism&oldid=5830"